Are you ready for the ultimate clash between Hive vs Tado?
I sure hope so because I’ve spent many hours researching smart thermostats to bring you this comprehensive comparison review.
First, we got Hive – the invention by British Gas that’s big on energy production. They guarantee an easy setup, great features, and a brilliant ecosystem. And then we have Tado – with a more minimalistic look yet still keeps heating & cooling fresh, but they don’t lose track of design or convenience either.
Alright, so which one will come out the winner?
We’ll dive deeply into their smart tech features and ecosystems to give you an idea of what differentiates them.
So strap in and get ready to enjoy this review!
Overview of Hive and Tado
Hive Active Heating Smart Thermostat
A smart way to heat your home
- Heating Scheduling
- Automatic Frost Protection
- Historical Data and Insights
- Heating Boosts and Holiday Mode
Hive Smart Thermostat is part of the larger ecosystem of other products like connected cameras, plugs, etc., making creating your own automated home easy. Moreover, Hive Smart Thermostat boasts an easy-to-use interface with a straightforward app and saving energy features like scheduling or geofencing. Plus, it can be part of a multi-room system, so each room’s temperature is adjustable independently!
- Subscription: Optional Hive Heating Plus at 3.99£ per month or 39.99£ per year
- Warranty: 1-year warranty, continuous with Hive Heating Plus
- Installation: DIY is possible, but professional installation is advised
- Power: AAA batteries x4
- Weight: 132 g
- Dimensions: 10.4 x 10 x 4.8 centimetres
- Self-learning: No
- Smart Voice Assistant: Google Home Assistant, Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit
- Hive Smart Radiator Valves: Yes, 54£ each
- It prevents frozen pipes in your home when the temperature drops below a certain threshold; the First Protection mode will automatically activate.
- Increase temperature quickly in your home with Heating Boost. Once activated, it will quickly increase the temperature in your home.
- Integrated your smart thermostat with other smart home devices due to the rich Hive ecosystem and compatibility with smart hubs like Alexa and SmartThings.
- Extended warranty and tracking features are only available with a valid subscription.
Tado Starter Kit V3+ Thermostat
An ideal choice for larger homes
- Weather Adaptation
- Open Window Detection
- Multi-Zone Control
- Smart Schedule
Tado Smart Thermostat primarily focuses on heating and cooling and does not offer many other smart home gadgets. On top of that, it was designed with energy consumption in mind, featuring extra features like open window detection and precise room temperature management. Also, the weather adaptation feature – the temps will adjust automatically depending on what’s happening outside! That way, you get perfect indoor temperatures no matter how cold or hot it is outside.
- Subscription: Optional Auto Assist at 2.99 per month
- Warranty: 2-year warranty
- Installation: DIY is possible, but professional installation is advised
- Power: Wireless and Wired
- Weight: 260 g
- Dimensions:10.4 x 10.4 x 1.8 centimetres
- Self-learning: No
- Smart Voice Assistant: Google Home Assistant, Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit
- Smart Radiator Valves: Yes, single for 69.99£ or three for 199.99£
- Keep a comfortable temperature in your home regardless of the weather outside due to the Weather Adaptation feature that will adjust the heating as needed.
- Save energy and money with Open Window Detection. The Tado will automatically switch off the heating if an open window is detected.
- Heat homes of any size due to the multi-room support that works with up to 25 heating devices.
- Open window detection and geofencing features are available with Auto Assist subscription only.
Quick Verdict: Hive or Tado?
For me, smart home devices are all about smart features and making your life more convenient, and smart thermostats are no different. Regarding price, both devices are close enough, so the preferred smart features should be the deciding factor.
If you’re all about energy efficiency and want to save money on your electricity bills, then Tado Smart Thermostat is worth considering. It has features like open window detection and weather adaptation to only turn the heating system on when needed. Furthermore, this thermostat can connect up to 25 smart heating devices, making it a great product for large households. Tado smart radiator valves are slightly more expensive (69.99£) than Hive’s (53.99£), so consider that if you need to buy many.
On the other hand, if you’re looking for something user-friendly and feature-packed, then Hive Smart Thermostat might be perfect. It boasts Frost Protection, so those cold winter months don’t lead to frozen pipes! Plus, Heating Boost offers an easy way of quickly warming up your home – convenience doesn’t get much better than this. If you already have some smart home setup (like SmartThings), this could fit right in – making it ideal if you value integration within various hubs.
Smart Platforms and Devices Ecosystem
Getting a smart thermostat means you’ll want it to be compatible with other home devices. An expansive device ecosystem is crucial if you want your house set up so that all components will work flawlessly together.
So, let’s take a closer look at how these two options fare regarding their compatibility and ecosystems: Hive and Tado.
The Hive Compatibility and Ecosystem
Hive has released several other products designed specifically so they can integrate smoothly with its smart thermostats. You’ll find window or door sensors, motion detectors, smart lights, smart light bulbs connected along Wi-Fi networks, and smart socket plugs as part of this platform’s family.
Hive’s got you covered when controlling all your devices from one centralized place via the Hive app. Plus, with its compatibility with popular smart platforms such as Google Home and Amazon Echo, adjusting temperatures is now accessible through voice commands, even for added convenience in syncing up other automation systems like SmartThings or Fibaro into your setup.
Tado Compatibility and Ecosystem
Regarding Tado compatibility and ecosystem, there are pros and cons compared to the Hive system.
While Tado offers an array of smart devices that work with its smart thermostat, it doesn’t have as many offerings as Hive. Instead, they focus more on creating heating and cooling solutions than providing various home automation solutions across different categories – like their Smart AC Control for air conditioning or individual radiator valves in each room.
Tado is compatible with most major smart home systems, such as Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, and Google Home, so you can easily connect your stuff without hassle.
The downside? You may not be able to access every device from one place – which could limit control over certain elements if you’re using multiple hubs or apps simultaneously.
In short, both companies provide good options when considering what’s best for your setup, but before making any decisions, make sure you understand what features matter most for you, plus how much freedom being limited by having just one platform affords you.
Key Features Comparison
Temperature Control and Scheduling
Both Hive and Tado feature user-friendly apps for temperature control and scheduling. You can quickly set timers, create schedules, or adjust your heating settings whenever possible. Other convenient features like frost protection for Hive or Weather Adaptation for Tado make these thermostats practical and energy efficient, ultimately saving home heating bills.
Geofencing and Location-Based Control
Tado’s smart system stands out with its location-based control abilities. The geofencing technology helps the central heating systems know when you’re coming home so they can prepare by setting a comfortable temperature according to your pre-selected settings.
You must get the Hive app on your smartphone first to use its smart thermostat Geolocation feature. And don’t forget to connect it to your smart thermostat, which can track where you are after enabling geolocation in the app.
So, for example, when users have left their house, meaning their phones leave a predefined ‘geofence,’ the smart thermostats switch into an energy-saving ‘away’ mode automatically. The thermostat can switch into “home” mode when the user reaches home once their smartphone is back within the geofence range. This allows it to alter its settings according to individual preferences.
Voice Assistant Integration
Thermostats optimized for integration with popular voice assistant platforms like Amazon Alexa or Google Home Assistant offer a convenient way of controlling them without getting up from your seat! Both Tado and Hive offer this convenience – and have ensured you can enjoy smart-integration technology in your homes.
Talking to a smart speaker or another device compatible with voice assistants allows consumers to control their home climate. Some examples of commands people can make are “Alexa, set the temperature at 72 degrees” and “Hey, Google, switch off the heat.”
Those who like being able to adjust their home’s cooling and heating system without having direct contact find this feature especially useful. Additionally, those who have disabilities or mobility problems, making it hard for them to interact directly with smart thermostats, may benefit as well.
Smart voice assistants are a great addition to smart thermostats since they aid in seamless connection with other connected tech and give customers an alternative simple solution for controlling their heating systems.
Energy Efficiency and Reporting
A big benefit of smart thermostats is their energy efficiency, as it can aid people to reduce money spent on electric bills plus lessen environmental impact. Tado places great focus on energy conservation here — they give tools and services that allow users to optimize their power consumption while reducing wastefulness.
Tado’s exact reporting on energy costs is one of its greatest assets. Through the Tado app, users can get a complete picture of their energy usage, including how much electricity they consume and what it costs them. By understanding exactly where their electricity use stands, consumers can recognize areas where they might make cost-saving adjustments.
In addition, Tado also offers suggestions. For example, the app may propose adjusting temperature settings to be more effective with your utility bill or suggest ways you could help reduce consumption while nobody’s home.
Extra energy cost-saving features Hive offers include location-based heating controls and scheduling options. While its reporting may not be as deep as Tado’s, the Hive app still provides some essential insight into your usage – though it might not be as comprehensive or adjustable compared to what Tado offers.
Both Tado and Hive support multi-zone control capabilities – a great feature that allows you to independently adjust temperatures in different parts of your home depending on where you need heat at any given moment. This is particularly helpful for bigger homes with multiple floors; instead of heating them all evenly, they can now have separate temps according to their needs.
Using multi-zone control, homeowners can keep the perfect temperature in every part of their place with separate settings for each zone. For instance, you could turn down the heat in your bedrooms while raising it when people use the living room during daylight hours – this way, you’ll save some money on energy bills.
Regarding energy conservation and lower heating bills, multi-zone control is a great feature of Tado or Hive. With these apps, managing different zones throughout your home becomes super simple!
You can enjoy huge energy savings by heating only those rooms that need attention at any moment.
Installation and Compatibility
The setup process for Tado and Hive smart thermostats may differ. The Tado is an easier installation, so it could be a big deal if you’re looking to save money on hiring a professional installer. Both these models are compatible with most boiler systems.
On the contrary, installing Hive might take some more effort because, should you go for its wired version, there’s got to be a physical connection between your heating system – which complicates things a little.
For those interested in multi-room control, both smart thermostats offer this feature at an additional cost. Consider your radiators when choosing between the Hive Smart Radiator Valve and Tado Smart Radiator Thermostat. Smart valves should fit without issues if your radiators have standard-sized T-valves.
Pricing and Subscription Plans
Now, let’s look into pricing plans for each smart thermostat system… Grasping the expenses associated will help you decide between these two smart thermostats.
Hive Pricing & Hive Heating Plus
Hive Active Heating Thermostat
The Hive Active Thermostat, including the Hive smart home hub, can be purchased for £179.
Hive Mini Thermostat
Hive mini is a smaller version of a Hive thermostat that offers less control on the actual device, but it is cheaper at 119£ while boasting similar features.
Hive Smart Radiator Valve
Multi-zone temperature control by attaching a smart valve to an individual radiator at £54 each.
Hive Heating Plus
An optional subscription plan is accessible for Hive Heating Plus at 3.99£ per month. The Hive Heating Plus service can estimate how much your heating needs will likely cost, relying on your past usage, energy efficiency, and energy tariff.
If you inform the app how much savings you would like to achieve, it can aid in creating a monthly budget. You’ll get use information from them every week, each month, and once a year, along with details showing whether or not you are staying within the allocated finances according to what was planned earlier.
Personalized tips on keeping within your energy budget are also available.
Tado Smart Thermostat Starter Kit V3+
The Tado Smart Thermostat Starter Kit has an official retail price of £199, but it can sometimes be found at a discounted price of £169.
Tado Smart Radiator Thermostats
Multi-zone control – attach a smart thermostat to a single radiator at £70 each.
Tado Smart AC Control
Control the air conditioning units with a Tado Smart AC Control device.
Tado Auto Assist
For an extra 2.99 per month, you can get the optional Auto Assist, which gives you access to additional functions like open window detections and monitoring of your electricity expenses with Energy IQ’s thorough breakdown of costs and usage info—also the monthly comparison for better control and visibility.
With Geofencing enabled in Auto-Assist, it can tell if someone is at home or arriving soon, so no electricity gets wasted when nobody’s around – plus a comfortable temperature will kick back in once they come home shortly after.
Suppose you attempted to let some fresh air into your home but forgot to turn down the temperature. No need to worry; tado° notices open windows and automatically changes your heating controls with its Auto-Assist feature. This helps cut back on needless energy usage and saves you money.
Hive vs Tado – Benefits and Drawbacks
Even though both smart thermostats share similar features, a few major differences may make one more suitable for certain customers. Let’s compare the benefits of using either Hive or Tado smart thermostat so buyers can decide which is best.
Hive Pros and Cons
Upon examining Hive’s features, I have noticed many great factors that many users appreciate.
Here’s what to know when considering if it’s right for you:
- Easy-to-use application interface
- Slightly cheaper smart radiator valves
- Lower price point compared to some competitors
- Compatibility with various smart home systems such as SmartThings through 3rd party custom implementations
However, there are also a few drawbacks to using Hive:
- Installation can take longer depending on the heating system
- Lack of self-learning
- It has a less sleek design than Tado unless you look at Hive Mini
- Requires subscription for some features
Tado Pros and Cons
The Tado has several key advantages that make it an appealing choice:
- Sleek design with an inconspicuous display
- GPS presence detection for precise temperature control
- Compatibility with smart home systems like Amazon Alexa and Google Home
- Comprehensive insights into energy tracking
Nonetheless, Tado also has a few downsides to consider:
- Higher price point than Hive
- Limited product range focused on energy and home environment control
- Tado smart radiator valves are also more expensive
- Requires Auto Assist for Geofencing and Open window detection
In my comparison of Hive vs. Tado smart thermostats, I think both systems offer various features to help users save energy and maintain a comfortable home environment.
The ability to integrate with a popular smart home system like Amazon Alexa and Google Home takes the user experience for both smart thermostats up a notch.
Tado stands out due to its use of smartphone location data and extra features available through subscription, which saves money and energy. At the same time, Hive emphasizes frost protection – something cold-weather homeowners may find particularly interesting.
Both offer great features that make them worth serious consideration – so think about what you need most from your smart thermostat before choosing!
Daniel Barczak is a software developer with a solid 9-year track record in the industry. Outside the office, Daniel is passionate about home automation. He dedicates his free time to tinkering with the latest smart home technologies and engaging in DIY projects that enhance and automate the functionality of living spaces, reflecting his enthusiasm and passion for smart home solutions.